Barry HarrisThe method

Tunes he taught

Cherokee

Barry used the bridge of Cherokee as a drill: a chain of major scales that turns into two dominants, played in time and then broken up with his descending-scale rules and 5-4-3 phrases. In interviews the tune stands for playing in every key, and for the fast dance numbers of his Detroit youth.

moments in class
21
recordings
8
Barry plays it
5

What he teaches through it

Map the bridge with plain scales. In a Hague class a student, Erik, played B major, A major and G major in turn; Barry then pointed out that the last two chords are dominants, so the major scales stop and you play C7 and F7. In the 1998 workshop he called the whole bridge as F♯7, B major, E7, A major, D7, G major, C7, F7, run up and down.

Major scales on the bridge of Cherokee0:351:081:41The 1998 workshop, part 31:07:221:08:13

The hard spot is the switch: the C7 has to come in straight after the G major, started on its seventh, with no gap. Barry ran it several times and said every pianist in the room would have to come up and play it.

Major scales on the bridge of Cherokee2:213:063:39

With the bridge in place he added a rule: coming down any scale, dominant or major, when you reach the fourth, jump to the second and climb chromatically to the third. Then he combined rules: run F♯7 up, make that move on the way down, sometimes go on chromatically from the third to the root, which is B major’s fifth, and there play five, four, then the move again.

The 1998 workshop, part 31:10:061:10:431:12:471:13:24

Cherokee was also a place for the 5-4-3-2 family of phrases. In a Hague class he asked for the four and the three, had the class stop there and feel it, and pointed out that five, four and three are the same on a dominant seventh as on a major.

5-4-3 phrases on Cherokee0:000:432:11

In the 1998 workshop he went from a blues to Cherokee, saying it is almost the same as what the class had just done on the four going to the four minor, and had them play its first part in B♭ with the melody.

The 1998 workshop, part 31:03:331:04:08

He once played Cherokee in every key with George Coleman at the Tin Palace in New York. Asked about it, he said it was not prepared key by key: you make yourself do it. What makes it possible is knowing the movements, the small automatic things many young players never learned.

Interview: Detroit, Bud Powell and the shuffle14:4615:20

Cherokee also belonged to his Detroit years of playing for dancers. More than once he told of the shake dancer Baby Scruggs, who asked the band to play it as fast as they could, and used the story to show that jazz and dancing once went together; they played for shake dancers, other dancers, shuffles and rhythm and blues alike.

Interview: Bird, Hawkins, Monk and New York33:0133:35Interview: Detroit and after12:06Barry Harris on WKCR-FM ¶63Barry Harris on WKCR-FM ¶64Barry Harris on WKCR-FM ¶65

In his own words

Those are dominants there. See, you don’t go to the major anymore, you go to dominants.

Major scales on the bridge of Cherokee, The Hague, 1989–98. Hague class, at the end of the Cherokee bridge, after the B, A and G major scales. 1:08 Watch on YouTube at 1:08

The bridge of Cherokee. Every scale, when you come down and you get to the four, I want you to play the second...

The 1998 workshop, part 3, The Hague, 1989–98. 1998 workshop, setting the rule for the bridge’s scales. 1:10:43 Watch on YouTube at 1:10:43

It’s not that I set up a practice in every key... There are certain moves that people are supposed to know, which they don’t know.

Interview: Detroit, Bud Powell and the shuffle, various, 1987–2019. Radio interview, on playing Cherokee in every key with George Coleman at the Tin Palace. 15:20 Watch on YouTube at 15:20

I wish people could have seen Baby Scruggs shake-dance while we played “Cherokee” fast.

Barry Harris on WKCR-FM. To Ted Panken, on playing for dancers in Detroit. ¶64

In class

Every moment he works on it, with the ideas of the method it shows.

Major scales on the bridge of Cherokee

The Hague, 1989–98

  1. 0:35

    Hague class: a student plays B, A and G major scales through the bridge.

    4.4

    Watch on YouTube at 0:35

  2. 1:08

    The last two chords are dominants: no more major scales.

    4.4

    Watch on YouTube at 1:08

  3. 1:41

    Names the tune; after G major, play C7 and F7.

    4.4

    Watch on YouTube at 1:41

  4. 2:21

    C7 started on its seventh, straight after the G major.

    Watch on YouTube at 2:21

  5. 3:39

    Every pianist will have to come up and play the switch.

    Watch on YouTube at 3:39

Counting through the bridge of Cherokee

The Hague, 1989–98

  1. 2:21

    Counts the class through the bridge from F♯7; the clip is mostly music.

    Watch on YouTube at 2:21

5-4-3 phrases on Cherokee

The Hague, 1989–98

  1. 0:00

    Asks for the four and the three on Cherokee.

    6.8

    Watch on YouTube

  2. 0:43

    Play the four and three, then stop there and feel it.

    6.8

    Watch on YouTube at 0:43

  3. 2:11

    Five, four and three work the same on a dominant seventh as on a major.

    6.8

    Watch on YouTube at 2:11

The 1998 workshop, part 3

The Hague, 1989–98

  1. 1:03:33

    1998 workshop: from the blues to the first part of Cherokee, in B♭ with the melody.

    Watch on YouTube at 1:03:33

  2. 1:08:13

    Calls the bridge: F♯7, B major, E7, A major, D7, G major, C7, F7, up and down.

    4.14.4

    Watch on YouTube at 1:08:13

  3. 1:08:58

    The class plays the bridge, then the last sixteen bars.

    Watch on YouTube at 1:08:58

  4. 1:10:06

    Rule: coming down, at the fourth play the second and go chromatically to the third.

    5.7

    Watch on YouTube at 1:10:06

  5. 1:10:43

    The rule on every scale of the bridge, played in time.

    5.7

    Watch on YouTube at 1:10:43

  6. 1:12:47

    Sometimes, from the third, go chromatically to the root, which is B major’s fifth.

    5.7

    Watch on YouTube at 1:12:47

  7. 1:13:24

    On B major’s fifth: five, four, then the move again.

    5.7

    Watch on YouTube at 1:13:24

The 23 May Zoom class, part 1

Online, from New Jersey), 2020

  1. 27:55

    2020 Zoom class: asks how the same phrase works on Cherokee; captions garbled.

    Watch on YouTube at 27:55

Interview: Detroit, Bud Powell and the shuffle

various, 1987–2019

  1. 14:46

    Recalls playing Cherokee in every key with George Coleman at the Tin Palace.

    14.2

    Watch on YouTube at 14:46

  2. 15:20

    Not prepared key by key: it comes from knowing movements young players lack.

    14.210.1

    Watch on YouTube at 15:20

Interview: Bird, Hawkins, Monk and New York

various, 1987–2019

  1. 33:35

    1988 radio: playing Cherokee as fast as possible for the shake dancer Baby Scruggs.

    Watch on YouTube at 33:35

Interview: Detroit and after

New York City, 2004

  1. 12:06

    Retells the Baby Scruggs story he used to tell his classes.

    Watch on YouTube at 12:06

Barry plays it

In the method

The ideas of the method these moments show, and how many moments each.

  1. 4.4Scale outlines4
  2. 5.7Coming down to the fourth4
  3. 6.8The 5-4-3-2 (and 4-3, 5-4-3-2-1) phrases3
  4. 14.2Every key, every degree, every way2
  5. 10.1Be a movement player1
  6. 4.1How Barry calls a scale (tonic to seventh, up/down/up and down)1