Barry HarrisThe method
13.1

The blues the Barry way

Barry taught the blues in layers: a plain scale plan for all twelve bars first, then the chords that move inside it (two diminished chords into the II, IV minor or the raised-four diminished) and pivots that join everything into one long line.

In plain words

The blues was one of Barry’s main teaching tunes, and he started it plain. In a class with horns he had a student recite the scale plan for a B♭ blues: B♭7 up, E♭7 up, B♭7 up and down, E♭7 up and down, B♭ major up and down to the third of G, F7 up and down, B♭ major up, F7 up. He expected everyone to know it that simply before he showed them anything hip.

Practising the blues with the horns, part 23:584:315:03Practising the blues with the horns, part 10:00

He also rejected the idea that a blues sits on one chord per bar. An A♭ blues moves A♭, A♭7, D♭, and its IV can be D♭, D♭ minor or the raised-four diminished (D diminished). Each chord takes the scale of the key it belongs to: going from B♭7 back to F in an F blues, B natural is wrong, and a D minor 7 in a B♭ blues belongs to B♭, so E natural there is a mistake.

The 1998 workshop, part 316:151:03:45Jazz theory, part 3: four dominants from one diminished4:044:37Student performances and coaching21:2221:57

The main device in bars 7 to 9 is a pair of diminished chords that lead to the II (C minor in B♭): one a half step below it, reached from B, the third of G, and one a half step above it, the E diminished (the same notes as C♯ diminished). A horn player may use either whenever he likes. Barry preferred the upper one: it also takes you home after E♭, and old-time slow blues used it instead of G7.

Practising the blues with the horns, part 11:113:364:086:347:4310:57

Then he joined the pieces into one line: scale, diminished, down to the seventh of F7 and a pivot, then another diminished onto the third of F. On Passport, a blues in C, he fixed the band’s changes to D minor to G, then E♭ minor to A♭7, and had the pianist play small three-note chords and short movements such as F7 changing to F♯ diminished and then to C.

Practising the blues with the horns, part 118:2219:3820:10Passport: teaching a blues by ear0:004:035:2112:1312:4913:57

Step by step

  1. Learn the plain plan and be able to say it aloud. In B♭: B♭7 up | E♭7 up | B♭7 up and down | E♭7 up and down | B♭ major up and down to the third of G | F7 up and down | B♭ major up | F7 up. ‘Up’ runs from the tonic to the seventh; ‘up and down’ comes back to the tonic.

    Practising the blues with the horns, part 24:31Practising the blues with the horns, part 10:00

  2. Into the II, use the diminished a half step below it: run B♭ major up and down to B, the third of G, then go up the B diminished to G, the second of F. The run fills bars 7 and 8 and one beat of bar 9.

    B♭ major up and down to the third of G, up the diminished, to the second of F
    𝄞♭♭♭♭
    1. B♭
    2. C
    3. D
    4. E♭
    5. F
    6. G
    7. A
    8. G
    9. F
    10. E♭
    11. D
    12. C
    13. B
    14. D
    15. F
    16. A♭
    17. G

    Practising the blues with the horns, part 11:113:003:36

  3. Or use the diminished a half step above the II: run B♭ major up to A and down to E♭ (the four), step up a half step to E, come down the E diminished and end on a low E♭.

    Up to the major seventh, down to the four, then down the E diminished
    𝄞♭♭♭♭♭♭
    1. B♭
    2. C
    3. D
    4. E♭
    5. F
    6. G
    7. A
    8. G
    9. F
    10. E♭
    11. E
    12. D♭
    13. B♭
    14. G
    15. E♭

    Practising the blues with the horns, part 14:084:425:21

  4. At the IV, choose the chord: in A♭, D♭, D♭ minor or D diminished (the raised four). In B♭, the E diminished after E♭ leads back to B♭.

    The 1998 workshop, part 316:15Practising the blues with the horns, part 110:57

  5. Join it into one line: B♭ major up and down to B, up the diminished, down the scale to E♭ (the seventh of F7), then pivot the chord on E♭: keep E♭ and play G, B♭, D an octave lower.

    One long line through bars 7–9, ending with the pivoted chord on E♭
    𝄞♭♭♭♭♭♭
    1. B♭
    2. C
    3. D
    4. E♭
    5. F
    6. G
    7. A
    8. G
    9. F
    10. E♭
    11. D
    12. C
    13. B
    14. D
    15. F
    16. A♭
    17. G
    18. F
    19. E♭
    20. G
    21. B♭
    22. D

    Practising the blues with the horns, part 112:0216:2217:5018:22

  6. Keep every chord in its own key: over a D minor 7 in a B♭ blues play E♭, not E; coming back from B♭7 to F in an F blues, stay in F major (no B natural).

    Student performances and coaching21:57Jazz theory, part 3: four dominants from one diminished4:37

an added note, outside the scale

How he said to practise it

  • Say the plan aloud as a class, then play it straight through in time. Barry wanted singers to recite the changes too before they scat.

    Practising the blues with the horns, part 24:31Practising the blues with the horns, part 19:5017:12

  • Practise pivoting on every chord of a scale; Barry said it keeps a line going when you think it will run out.

    Practising the blues with the horns, part 114:2615:1315:47

  • Play one phrase over and over through the form without losing time. If it starts on the tonic on the first beat, drop its first two notes so it starts on the second beat.

    Practising the blues with the horns, part 123:1423:4825:08

In Barry’s words

Each one plays from the moment he says it. Every other moment he teaches it is listed below.

Some people are telling you that... the blues is A-flat seven for full measures. That’s ridiculous.

The 1998 workshop, part 3, The Hague, 1989–98. Working through an A♭ blues; next he lists D♭, D♭ minor and D diminished for the IV. 16:15 Watch on YouTube at 16:15

If I was playing some slow blues, I don’t like the G7 at all.

Practising the blues with the horns, part 1, The Hague, 1989–98. On the diminished a half step above the II, which old-time slow blues used. 7:48 Watch on YouTube at 7:48

If you want to scat and stuff, you got to know changes too.

Practising the blues with the horns, part 1, The Hague, 1989–98. Making the singers in a horn class say the blues changes aloud. 9:50 Watch on YouTube at 9:50

That doesn’t necessarily mean big chords up at the top. Just little chords.

Passport: teaching a blues by ear, The Hague, 1989–98. Coaching a band on Passport, a blues in C: what a bebop pianist plays. 7:01 Watch on YouTube at 7:01

Where this comes from

Everything above is drawn from these. Open any one to check it.

Every moment he teaches it12 moments in 6 recordings

Each time opens the transcript there; the video plays when you are online.

Practising the blues with the horns, part 2

The Hague, 1989–98 — 8 min On YouTube

  1. 4:31

    A student recites the whole B♭ blues scale plan; Barry expects everyone to know it.

    Watch on YouTube at 4:31

Practising the blues with the horns, part 1

The Hague, 1989–98 — 26 min On YouTube

  1. 1:11

    B♭ major up and down to the third of G, then up the diminished to the second of F.

    Watch on YouTube at 1:11

  2. 3:36

    Two diminished chords lead to the II: a half step below it and a half step above.

    Watch on YouTube at 3:36

  3. 5:21

    The upper one: B♭ major up to A, down to E♭, half step up, down the E diminished.

    Watch on YouTube at 5:21

  4. 7:43

    Bass players think it is always the lower one; in slow blues Barry drops the G7s.

    Watch on YouTube at 7:43

  5. 10:57

    After E♭ the E diminished takes you back to B♭; why the upper one is most interesting.

    Watch on YouTube at 10:57

  6. 18:22

    Builds one line: scale, diminished, down to the seventh of F7, then a pivot.

    Watch on YouTube at 18:22

The 1998 workshop, part 3

The Hague, 1989–98 — 76 min On YouTube

  1. 16:15

    An A♭ blues is not A♭7 for a bar; the IV can be D♭, D♭ minor or D diminished.

    Watch on YouTube at 16:15

Passport: teaching a blues by ear

The Hague, 1989–98 — 16 min On YouTube

  1. 4:03

    Passport, blues in C: corrects the band’s changes to D minor–G, then E♭ minor–A♭7.

    Watch on YouTube at 4:03

  2. 12:13

    Passport: the pianist changes F7 to a diminished, then to C, with three-note chords.

    Watch on YouTube at 12:13

Student performances and coaching

New York City, 2004 — 45 min On YouTube

  1. 21:22

    After a student blues: not every minor seventh is the same; no E natural on D minor 7 in B♭.

    Watch on YouTube at 21:22

Jazz theory, part 3: four dominants from one diminished

New York City — 12 min On YouTube

  1. 4:04

    In an F blues, players wrongly play B natural going from B♭ back to F.

    Watch on YouTube at 4:04

From the lessons4 lessons, 10 points

Notes taken from Barry’s classes, each tied to the moment it comes from.

The blues is more than one chord per bar

  1. Exercise

    The simplest scale plan for a blues in B flat, which Barry expects you to know just that simply before any hip stuff: B flat 7 up; E flat 7 up; B flat 7 up and down; E flat 7 up and down; B flat major up and down to the third of G; F7 up and down; B flat major up; F7 up. He warned a student who goofed to be sure to play B flat major where the plan calls for it.

    Practising the blues with the horns, part 23:584:31

  2. Idea

    Barry rejects the idea that a blues in A flat just sits on A flat 7 for a full measure. The opening moves A flat, A flat 7, then D flat, and the four chord can also be D flat minor or D diminished (the raised-four diminished). The blues is more than one chord per measure, and he notes that the start of Cherokee works almost the same way as this I-to-IV material.

    The 1998 workshop, part 315:4316:151:03:45

Every chord takes the scale it comes from

  1. Idea

    Barry criticises players who, in an F blues, go from the B flat chord back to F and suddenly play B natural. That note doesn’t belong in the F major scale. His principle: every chord takes the scale it comes from, so you have to know the chord on each degree of the scale and which scale it belongs to.

    Jazz theory, part 3, with score4:26

  2. Exercise

    Not every minor seventh is the same. A C minor 7 can belong to B flat, E flat or A flat, and each takes a different scale: the B flat major, E flat major or A flat major scale. In a B flat blues, Barry says, playing E natural when you reach the D minor 7 is a drag, because it shows you think that chord is in the key of C rather than B flat. Make the distinction: know which key each minor seventh belongs to before choosing your notes.

    Student performances and coaching21:1521:50

Two diminished chords that lead to the two

  1. Exercise

    In a B flat blues, run the B flat major scale up and down to the third of G (B natural), then go up the diminished from that note. This falls in bars 7 and 8 and one beat into bar 9. It is a diminished that takes you to the two: the one a half step below the two. Barry said he doesn’t believe in ‘two’ chords, but uses the word because horn players need some harmony to think in.

    Practising the blues with the horns, part 11:113:003:36

  2. Exercise

    A second diminished also leads to the two: the one a half step above it. In a B flat blues this is the E diminished (E is a half step above E flat, the four). Run the B flat major scale up to the major seventh and down to the four (E flat). Step up a half step to E concert, run down the E diminished seventh chord, and end on E flat.

    Practising the blues with the horns, part 13:364:42

  3. Idea

    In the blues a horn player can use either diminished whenever he likes, regardless of what the rhythm section plays. Barry finds the upper one, E diminished in B flat, the most interesting: it leads to the two and also back to the one. For example, after the E flat major you can play E diminished to return to B flat. The lower one only takes you to the two. He compared the upper one to being taken up to heaven and brought back down to earth.

    Practising the blues with the horns, part 16:3410:2410:57

  4. Idea

    At that spot in the blues, bass players tend to assume the diminished is always the one a half step below the two. They need to know the one above as well, because both are equally important. In a real old-time slow blues Barry doesn’t like the G7s at all; that style uses the upper diminished instead, and he played it to show how pretty it sounds.

    Practising the blues with the horns, part 16:347:43

  5. Exercise

    Then string the devices into one longer blues line, as Barry had the horns do: run up the B flat major scale and down to G, go up the diminished, come down the scale to the seventh of F7, then pivot (as with the diminished: play it up, hit its first note and bring the other notes down). He had them repeat it, then play it over the blues, and next added another diminished on the third of F.

    Practising the blues with the horns, part 112:0217:5018:2219:03

Passport: two ii-Vs a half step apart

  1. Exercise

    Coaching a band on Passport, Barry corrected the changes at one spot: play D minor to G, then E flat minor to A flat 7. These are two ii-V pairs a half step apart, and they lead back to the start of the song. He also told a player who struggled to drop down low that he could just stay up there instead.

    Passport: teaching a blues by ear4:034:425:21

In writing8 notes

What his interviews, his students’ class notes and other teachers’ articles add.

How other teachers explain it12 videos, 25 series episodes

Barry’s students, and their students, teaching it their way. A second opinion, not Barry.

In the teaching series

Episodes on this idea in the long series by other teachers. Each name opens that whole series in order.

Where the accounts differ1 point
Read further6 links

These open on the web.

Free to read

Books and paid courses