Barry HarrisThe method

Tunes he taught

Chi Chi

The uploader of Barry’s 1998 workshop in The Hague says this part explores Charlie Parker’s Chi-Chi, a blues in A-flat, along with Cherokee. Barry never says the title in the captions, but he spends much of the class on the A-flat blues: its chords, the half-step rule on the A-flat major scale, an offbeat phrase, and a link to Cherokee.

moments in class
22
recordings
1
Barry plays it
1

What he teaches through it

The blues in A-flat is not four bars of A-flat seventh, Barry said; calling it that is ridiculous. It goes A-flat to A-flat 7 to D-flat, and from there it can be D-flat minor or D diminished, the raised-fourth diminished. Earlier he pointed out that the one goes to a major four, not a dominant four, and then to the minor four on the way back to the one.

The 1998 workshop, part 38:098:4015:4416:21

Know the basic material: all your triads, minor arpeggios and diminished chords. Taking the D-flat minor arpeggio in one position, from D-flat to D-flat, he pointed out that its four notes can be played in 24 orders, and that you should know every one.

The 1998 workshop, part 31:336:0313:0214:44

You should know surrounding notes: the fifth of A-flat, E-flat, can be surrounded by E and D, the notes a half step either side of it.

The 1998 workshop, part 317:33

Coming down the A-flat major scale, put a half step between the sixth and fifth, F and E-flat; played plain, he said, the scale does not sound like anything. Run it down from each degree of the scale and notice where the added half step has to go. The rules, he reminded the class, matter more than the scale.

The 1998 workshop, part 330:3233:3735:1936:0038:15

He set words to a short phrase, ‘don’t go’, asking the class to imagine someone they love suddenly having to leave town. The phrase had to start off the beat: the beat is close to hell, he told them, and the ‘and’ close to heaven. Later he stopped them again for starting right on the beat.

The 1998 workshop, part 344:2645:0455:19

To show that the blues is more than one chord, he said the opening of Cherokee is almost the same as what the class had just played on the four going to the four minor, and had them play the first part of Cherokee in B-flat with the melody.

The 1998 workshop, part 31:03:33

In his own words

The blues is A-flat to A-flat seven to D-flat, it can be the D-flat minor and it could be the D diminished. The four sharp diminished.

The 1998 workshop, part 3, The Hague, 1989–98. The Hague, 1998, right after rejecting the idea that the blues in A-flat is four bars of one chord. 16:21 Watch on YouTube at 16:21

Can you imagine? The one you love has to... leave town and you say don’t go

The 1998 workshop, part 3, The Hague, 1989–98. Setting up a short phrase for the class to play over the A-flat blues, The Hague, 1998. 44:26 Watch on YouTube at 44:26

In class

Every moment he works on it, with the ideas of the method it shows.

The 1998 workshop, part 3

The Hague, 1989–98

  1. 8:09

    The one goes to a major four, not a dominant four, then to the minor four.

    10.77.3

    Watch on YouTube at 8:09

  2. 9:14

    Try a D-flat minor arpeggio down to the fifth of A-flat.

    Watch on YouTube at 9:14

  3. 10:15

    What Bird does with that spot: D natural instead of D-flat at the bottom; class tries both.

    Watch on YouTube at 10:15

  4. 10:56

    He could have made up the song differently: the class plays a simpler version.

    Watch on YouTube at 10:56

  5. 13:02

    The D-flat minor arpeggio in one position can be played 24 ways; know them all.

    6.4

    Watch on YouTube at 13:02

  6. 16:15

    The A-flat blues is not one chord: A-flat, A-flat 7, D-flat, D-flat minor or D diminished.

    13.1

    Watch on YouTube at 16:15

  7. 17:33

    Surrounding notes: E and D around E-flat, the fifth of A-flat.

    6.5

    Watch on YouTube at 17:33

  8. 24:31

    The seventh of A-flat 7 leads to D-flat, but he wants more than a plain A-flat 7 there.

    Watch on YouTube at 24:31

  9. 27:02

    Introduces a phrase with what sounds like ‘Bird might say something like’; the scat is garbled.

    Watch on YouTube at 27:02

  10. 30:32

    From the major seventh down to the five, with a half step between six and five.

    5.2

    Watch on YouTube at 30:32

  11. 33:37

    Run on down the scale to the tonic, from each degree of it.

    5.214.2

    Watch on YouTube at 33:37

  12. 35:19

    The rules are more important than the scale.

    0.3

    Watch on YouTube at 35:19

  13. 36:00

    Without the half step between F and E-flat, the plain A-flat scale does not sound like anything.

    5.2

    Watch on YouTube at 36:00

  14. 37:09

    Practise starting on the ‘and’, not on the beat, from every degree of A-flat.

    1.35.4

    Watch on YouTube at 37:09

  15. 38:15

    Starting on B-flat, the added half step moves to between G and F.

    5.2

    Watch on YouTube at 38:15

  16. 40:28

    Play it again but end on the third of F.

    7.3

    Watch on YouTube at 40:28

  17. 42:35

    Diminished off the third of F; the last note is the fifth of B-flat minor, which comes from E-flat 7.

    Watch on YouTube at 42:35

  18. 44:26

    Sets the words ‘don’t go’ to a phrase: someone you love has to leave town.

    12.3

    Watch on YouTube at 44:26

  19. 45:04

    Off the beat: the beat is close to hell, the ‘and’ close to heaven.

    7.51.3

    Watch on YouTube at 45:04

  20. 46:45

    A nice place to bring in the minor arpeggio.

    Watch on YouTube at 46:45

  21. 55:19

    Stops the class: don’t start right on the beat like that.

    7.5

    Watch on YouTube at 55:19

  22. 1:03:33

    The blues is more than one chord; Cherokee’s opening is almost the same. Class plays Cherokee.

    13.1

    Watch on YouTube at 1:03:33

Barry plays it

In the method

The ideas of the method these moments show, and how many moments each.

  1. 5.2Major scale descending4
  2. 1.3Feel the ‘ands’2
  3. 13.1The blues the Barry way2
  4. 7.3Getting through changes2
  5. 7.5Rhythmic placement2
  6. 0.3Rules matter more than scales; everything by logic1
  7. 10.7Movements classical pianists know1
  8. 12.3Phrase like speech; place entries in time; ballads1