Barry HarrisThe method
9.1

Sixth chords ruleM7 = major 6, m7b5 = minor 6

Barry treated every minor seventh as a major sixth and every half-diminished chord as a minor sixth: Am7 is C6, Em7♭5 is Gm6. As sixth chords they belong to a sixth diminished scale, which tells you where to move them.

In plain words

A minor seventh chord and a major sixth chord can be the same four notes: A, C, E, G is A minor seventh or C major sixth. Barry first met this in his first theory book and did not see why it mattered; later he called it important. His rule was simple: when you see the minor seventh, know at once which major sixth it is.

Jazz theory, part 6: every major sixth is a minor seventh0:32Jazz theory, part 4: borrowing diminished notes6:186:53Sixth chords and their relatives1:37

The half-diminished chord works the same way with a minor sixth: Barry told a class that every minor sixth is a half-diminished. In Star Eyes, at the spot where most players would just play G half-diminished, he heard B♭ minor with its sixth in the bass, which put him in the B♭ minor sixth diminished scale.

Sixth chords and their relatives1:37Star Eyes: a minor sixth for the half-diminished0:00

The point is movement. A pianist may play a good chord and still not know that it belongs to a scale of chords; once you know the scale, you know where the chord can move. Barry tied the minor-seventh rule straight to the sixth diminished scale, because the major sixth is the chord that scale is built on.

Jazz theory, part 4: borrowing diminished notes6:537:27Jazz theory, part 6: every major sixth is a minor seventh0:32

It also changes how you hear a progression. Following Monk, Barry heard D half-diminished as F minor with D in the bass, so the progression is a minor four going to five and one, not a two-five; in the same way D minor seventh is really F major, a four chord going to five and one.

The C minor seventh in All the Things You Are6:347:10

Step by step

  1. Minor seventh to major sixth: the major sixth is built on the minor seventh’s third, a minor third above its root. Same four notes, different bottom note.

    Am7 = C6
    𝄞
    1. C
    2. E
    3. G
    4. A
    Dm7 = F6
    𝄞
    1. F
    2. A
    3. C
    4. D

    Jazz theory, part 6: every major sixth is a minor seventh0:32Vera Marijt (research coach Jarmo Hoogendijk), Barry Harris: Exploring the Diminished (MA research paper) ¶84Howard Rees’ Jazz Workshops, Major & Minor 6th Dim. Scales: Becoming Familiar with the 6th Diminished Scales ¶17

  2. Half-diminished to minor sixth: the minor sixth is likewise built a minor third above the root of the half-diminished chord.

    Em7♭5 = Gm6
    𝄞♭
    1. G
    2. B♭
    3. D
    4. E
    G half-diminished = B♭m6 (Star Eyes)
    𝄞♭♭
    1. B♭
    2. D♭
    3. F
    4. G

    Sixth chords and their relatives1:37Star Eyes: a minor sixth for the half-diminished0:00Vera Marijt (research coach Jarmo Hoogendijk), Barry Harris: Exploring the Diminished (MA research paper) ¶85Howard Rees’ Jazz Workshops, Major & Minor 6th Dim. Scales: Becoming Familiar with the 6th Diminished Scales ¶17

  3. Then pair the sixth chord with its diminished chord, the one built a half step below its root, and move the chord along the scale the two make together.

    Gm6 with F♯ diminished (+): the G minor sixth diminished scale
    𝄞♭♭♯
    1. G
    2. A
    3. B♭
    4. C
    5. D
    6. E♭
    7. E
    8. F♯

    Practising the sixth diminished scales4:10Howard Rees, Chord Explorations ¶28Howard Rees’ Jazz Workshops, Major & Minor 6th Dim. Scales: Becoming Familiar with the 6th Diminished Scales ¶17Howard Rees, Evolutionary Voicings, Part I: Barry Harris Keeps Things Movin’ ¶27

an added note, outside the scale

How he said to practise it

  • Know both conversions by heart, so that a minor seventh brings its major sixth to mind at once and a half-diminished its minor sixth; Barry said everybody has to know this.

    Jazz theory, part 6: every major sixth is a minor seventh0:32Sixth chords and their relatives1:37

  • To show what the C sixth diminished scale gives you, Barry had students play A minor seventh and, in place of its G, borrow G♯, a diminished note of that scale, then let it fall back to G.

    Introducing the sixth diminished scale10:4611:20

In Barry’s words

Each one plays from the moment he says it. Every other moment he teaches it is listed below.

Every major six is a minor seven

Jazz theory, part 6: every major sixth is a minor seventh, New York City. Linking the rule to the sixth diminished scale 0:32 Watch on YouTube at 0:32

Every minor six is a half diminished

Sixth chords and their relatives. Reminding a class of the two conversions everyone has to know 1:33 Watch on YouTube at 1:33

Each [chord] he played belongs to a scale... then you know where to move it

Jazz theory, part 4: borrowing diminished notes, New York City. On a pianist who plays good chords but does not know the scale of chords 6:53 Watch on YouTube at 6:53

Here’s C6. It’s A [minor] 7 but it’s C6

Barry Harris: Using Major 6 Diminished scale (with Live Transcript), Spain, 2007–08. About to move the chord contrary along the C sixth diminished scale 1:00 Watch on YouTube at 1:00

Where this comes from

Everything above is drawn from these. Open any one to check it.

Every moment he teaches it9 moments in 7 recordings

Each time opens the transcript there; the video plays when you are online.

Jazz theory, part 6: every major sixth is a minor seventh

New York City — 10 min On YouTube

  1. 0:32

    Every major sixth is a minor seventh: see A minor, know C major sixth, for the sixth diminished scale.

    Watch on YouTube at 0:32

Jazz theory, part 4: borrowing diminished notes

New York City — 8 min On YouTube

  1. 6:18

    Recalls reading ‘every major six is a minor seven’ in his first theory book before seeing its importance.

    Watch on YouTube at 6:18

  2. 6:53

    A pianist must know each chord belongs to a scale of chords, so he knows where to move it.

    Watch on YouTube at 6:53

Barry Harris: Using Major 6 Diminished scale (with Live Transcript)

Spain, 2007–08 — 3 min On YouTube

  1. 1:00

    ‘It’s A minor 7 but it’s C6’: takes the chord contrary along the C sixth diminished scale.

    Watch on YouTube at 1:00

Star Eyes: a minor sixth for the half-diminished

The Hague, 1989–98 — 1 min On YouTube

  1. 0:00

    Star Eyes: hears B♭ minor with the sixth in the bass instead of G half-diminished, and moves through its scale.

    Watch on YouTube

Sixth chords and their relatives

5 min On YouTube

  1. 1:37

    Reminds the class that every major sixth is a minor seventh and every minor sixth a half-diminished.

    Watch on YouTube at 1:37

The C minor seventh in All the Things You Are

The Hague, 1989–98 — 8 min On YouTube

  1. 6:34

    Monk’s view: D half-diminished is F minor with the sixth in the bass, a minor four, not a two.

    Watch on YouTube at 6:34

  2. 7:10

    D minor seventh is really F major, four to five to one; not every C minor seventh is the same.

    Watch on YouTube at 7:10

Introducing the sixth diminished scale

The Hague, 1989–98 — 27 min On YouTube

  1. 10:46

    After the C sixth diminished scale, has students play A minor seventh and borrow G♯ for its G.

    Watch on YouTube at 10:46

From the lessons2 lessons, 7 points

Notes taken from Barry’s classes, each tied to the moment it comes from.

Building the scale: a sixth chord plus the missing diminished

  1. Idea

    Start from C6 (C, E, G, A). Barry points out that its notes come from two of the three diminished seventh chords: E and G belong to one, C and A to another. The third diminished chord (D, F, A-flat, B) has no notes in C6, so you add it, and C6 plus that diminished chord is the scale: C D E F G A-flat A B. In other words, a major scale with an extra note between the fifth and the sixth.

    Introducing the sixth diminished scale1:081:43

  2. Idea

    The same method works from other chords. Barry notes that the dominant seventh, minor sixth, major sixth and seventh-flat-five chords all come from two of the diminished chords, then asks his secret question: what do you do with the third diminished, none of whose notes are in those chords? Combine it with them. With B7 the third diminished is C-sharp diminished; take the next inversion and you have B major sixth with that diminished, which together make the B major sixth diminished scale.

    Jazz theory, part 5: the sixth diminished scale4:265:035:387:03

  3. Idea

    Every major sixth chord is also a minor seventh chord: C major 6 has the same notes as A minor 7. Barry remembered reading this in his first theory book without seeing why it mattered; later he understood its importance. When you see a minor seventh chord you should know its major sixth, because the major sixth is what makes the sixth diminished scale.

    Jazz theory, part 6: every major sixth is a minor seventh0:32Jazz theory, part 4: borrowing diminished notes6:186:53

  4. Idea

    What the scale gives you, according to Barry: it contains not only the dominant of the major key but also the dominant of the relative minor. It also gives you a scale of chords, which you should know. As he builds it he names the chords in turn: six, diminished, six, diminished.

    Introducing the sixth diminished scale2:16Practising the sixth diminished scales0:03

The half-diminished is a minor chord with the sixth in the bass

  1. Idea

    Monk described the first chord of ‘Round Midnight as a minor chord with the sixth in the bass. Barry had learned it as minor seventh flat five, and others call it half-diminished, but for Barry Monk’s description was all it took: play any notes of C minor and put A, the sixth, in the bass, and you have A half-diminished.

    Believe: a talk to musicians22:3523:0723:43

  2. Idea

    Whenever you play a half-diminished chord, know immediately which major key it comes from: it is the relative minor of that major with the sixth in the bass. B-flat half-diminished comes from E major (C-sharp, or D-flat, minor with B-flat below); C half-diminished from G-flat major (E-flat minor with C below); D half-diminished is F minor with the sixth in the bass, so its major is A-flat. Knowing the parent major tells you where the chord came from and how to get there. Barry says standards that go to odd-sounding places, such as I Love You, work this way.

    Stella by Starlight10:3011:0212:49Borrowed diminished notes on All the Things You Are16:15

  3. Exercise

    You also have to know how to get to the half-diminished; certain chords lead to certain chords, and you have to play the major to get there. Barry’s route to A half-diminished: start from E-flat major, go to its relative minor, C minor, then put the sixth (A) in the bass. He adds that the chord really belongs to B-flat major, the only place you find it, so you had to change the E-flat major into B-flat major to get to it. He tried it many different ways, and said bass players, for example, do not know these things.

    Believe: a talk to musicians23:4324:2124:5925:32

In writing7 notes

What his interviews, his students’ class notes and other teachers’ articles add.

How other teachers explain it4 videos, 35 series episodes

Barry’s students, and their students, teaching it their way. A second opinion, not Barry.

In the teaching series

Episodes on this idea in the long series by other teachers. Each name opens that whole series in order.

Where the accounts differ1 point
  • Barry said he used to claim there was no such thing as a half-diminished chord until someone corrected him; he then passed on Monk’s description, a minor chord with the sixth in the bass.

    The C minor seventh in All the Things You Are6:006:34

Read further4 links

These open on the web.

Books and paid courses